The Real Reason Cindy Williams Walked Away From ‘Laverne & Shirley’

When Cindy Williams left Laverne & Shirley in 1982, the exit felt abrupt to viewers and confusing even to those working on the show. Shirley Feeney was half of one of television’s most beloved duo, and suddenly she was gone halfway through the series’ California years. Over the decades, fans have often wondered whether the sitcom ever seriously considered continuing without Shirley, or even reinventing itself entirely around Penny Marshall‘s Laverne. In later interviews, both Penny and her brother, series creator Garry Marshall addressed what really happened behind the scenes, and their comments reveal how uncertain and emotionally complicated that period truly was.

Why Cindy Williams really left Laverne & Shirley

In a Television Academy Foundation interview, Penny Marshall explained that she knew about Williams’ personal life changes early on. “I was aware she got married, ’cause I was at the wedding. I was aware she was pregnant, ’cause I could see and she told me,” Penny said.

What she did not anticipate was how difficult production would become as Williams’ husband became increasingly involved behind the scenes. Penny described the situation as “all this insanity,” stressing that her frustration was not directed at Williams herself. “It wasn’t Cindy,” she emphasized, explaining that communication eventually became so strained she could not even reach her co-star directly.

Everett Collection

The emotional toll extended beyond the set. Penny admitted that once Williams left, she dreaded facing the studio audience and the inevitable questions. “Going out in front of the audience and they say, ‘What happened with Cindy?’ and having to explain, it’s a drag,” she said. Penny also noted that she happened to have an out date in her contract, which spared her from having to remain in the spotlight much longer during the transition.

How Laverne & Shirley could have gone on without Shirley

With Williams gone, the show briefly experimented with guest appearances and storylines. Penny recalled calling friends and colleagues to help fill the gap, including Louise Linton, Jim Belushi and Anjelica Huston. One episode even flirted with the idea of introducing a new sister figure for Laverne, but Penny was firm that it was never meant as a true replacement.

Contract issues only added to the tension. Penny explained that although Williams was no longer appearing regularly, contractual arrangements still reflected the original two-star structure, which frustrated her. Looking back, Penny described the end of her time on the show as emotionally unresolved rather than celebratory. “There was no ending. It was anticlimactic,” she said, noting that her final appearances were scattered across episodes rather than forming a clean farewell.

Paramount/Everett Collection

Garry Marshall offered a wider perspective on the situation in a separate interview, acknowledging that Williams had been restless even before her pregnancy. “Cindy wasn’t really happy on the show. She wanted to do other things,” Garry said. He explained that industry dynamics had shifted by that time and that studios were no longer shielding productions from gossip and internal conflict the way they once had. Once Williams left, he felt the show’s creative balance changed noticeably. “The last years of Laverne & Shirley were a little tough, because Penny had to carry herself, and it wasn’t as good in my opinion,” Garry said.

Garry also addressed why replacing Shirley was never truly viable. Unlike Happy Days, which successfully shifted focus when characters departed, Laverne & Shirley depended entirely on the chemistry between its two leads. “Laverne and Shirley was a great team,” Garry said. He noted that the production did try introducing other characters, but “nobody really worked.”

The Surprising Inspiration Behind 'Laverne & Shirley'

It was a family matter.

Remind

Want More?

Classic Comedy Duos

March 2021

Chuckle at television & films funniest comic duos.

Buy This Issue