‘Little House on the Prairie’: Whatever Happened to Merlin Olsen, Who Played Jonathan Garvey?

Merlin Olsen, portrait, date unknown
Everett Collection

What To Know

  • Merlin Olsen, a former NFL star and Hall of Famer, became a beloved actor on Little House on the Prairie.
  • In addition to his acting career, Olsen was recognized as one of the 100 Greatest Football Players of all time.
  • Olsen is remembered for his achievements in sports, television, and his devoted family life.

Growing up, it was hard to miss Merlin Olsen on television. While professional football was a big part of his life each Sunday, first as a player and then as a sports broadcaster, he also became a familiar face on primetime television. Beginning in 1977, Olsen took on the role of Jonathan Garvey on Little House on the Prairie, joining the beloved series after Victor French departed to star in the ABC sitcom Carter Country.

When Olsen joined Little House, he knew that filling French’s shoes would be no small task, especially since his character, Mr. Edwards, was so beloved by fans. Olsen also expressed some anxiety about the number of lines he would have to memorize, but according to the official Little House on the Prairie website, producer Michael Landon reassured him, saying, “If I didn’t think you could do it, I wouldn’t let you do it.”

Olsen’s character was so well-received that when French returned to Little House on the Prairie, Landon began thinking about how else he could leverage Olsen’s talents and, in 1981, Olsen ended up headlining his very own show, Father Murphy, which ran for two seasons on NBC. In that series, Olsen’s character disguises himself as a priest to help a group of orphans threatened with being sent to a poorhouse destined for a life of hard labor.

FATHER MURPHY, Merlin Olsen, Mine the dog, (Season 1), 1981-83.

Everett Collection

After Father Murphy ended, Olsen then starred in the very short-lived NBC sitcom Fathers and Sons, which lasted only four episodes, followed by another NBC family drama called Aaron’s Way, about an Amish family that moves to California. While it had its devoted fans, not enough people tuned in, and the network gave it the ax after just 14 episodes.

Throughout all of these acting roles, Olsen was still working weekends as a sports broadcaster. Incredibly articulate, he was highly sought-after as a color commentator during football broadcasts. Returning to his athletic achievements for a moment, it is critical to mention that the Los Angeles Rams defensive lineman was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1982, and in 1999, The Sporting News included him on its list of the 100 Greatest Football Players of all time.

Sadly, in 2009, Olsen was diagnosed with mesothelioma, a form of cancer caused by asbestos exposure. Always the fighter, he underwent three rounds of chemotherapy over the course of the next year, all to no avail; he passed away in 2010 at the far too young age of 69.

DICK ENBERG and MERLIN OLSEN, are the NBC sportscasters hosting the NFL contest, on Thanksgiving Day, 11/23/78.

Everett Collection

While his early death was a tragedy, it is far more important to remember that Olsen’s life was anything but tragic. Putting acting and sports aside, Olsen found the love of his life while attending Utah State University and remained married to her for 48 years. Together, they raised three wonderful children who grew into equally remarkable adults. In short, his life was a great triumph.

Perhaps Olsen’s younger brother Phil, who was also one of his Los Angeles Rams teammates, said it best when he told a journalist for the Cache Valley Daily that throughout his life, Merlin was admired, respected, and loved. He went on to quip that when he felt an earthquake a few months after his brother’s passing, “We figured it was Merlin getting his first quarterback sack in heaven.”

Little House on the Prairie (Expanded Issue)
Want More?

Little House on the Prairie (Expanded Issue)

TV Guide Puzzler

This special issue is packed with tons of trivia and puzzles, including word searches, crosswords, criss crosses, spot the differences and more all about America's favorite frontier family.

Buy This Issue